Archive for the 'wonkish policy stuff' Category

Primaries, Reflections From 2004

Friday, April 25th, 2008

For what its worth, I thought I’d make it a point to make more regular posts at least for my crazy finals prep week(s) It sort of allows a mental break from reading case law. I’ve been fortunate enough to have a few days advanced leave from work due to my trip going over the weekend. I usually plan to take some leave around this time of year months in advance, but it seems like more often than any extra time to prepare is welcomed.

Occasionally I browse past the archives of this journal to see what I was thinking, 6 months ago, one year ago, 4 years ago, etc. It’s pretty amazing how much I was following the primaries back in 2004, and how little I’ve written about them this year. It’s not that I haven’t been following them any less, more or less its because I think I’m a bit wiser or at least more cynical maybe about the entire process in general. I’ve already been following a candidate, for those who know me well enough, and have been watching the debates should know exactly who that person is. Back in 2004 I was following Howard Dean’s run at the Democratic nomination and was pretty disappointed when and especially how he fell behind the eventual nominee John Kerry. The fall of Dean really spoke to me about the power of the media to phrase and showcase a candidate’s strengths and flaws. I remember hearing the “Dean Scream” and not thinking much of it until it was blasted all over the TV as indicative of his un-electability.

This time around the candidate that I’m supporting speaks to a lot of beliefs and opinions that I’ve held ever since I was very young, but couldn’t quite identify them fully, mostly due to the black/white blue-state/red-state, good/evil mentality that live in today. I’d say that since 2004 I’ve had kind of a gradual revelation of sorts driven by working in the real world, some self reflection/observation and just keeping an eye on the events around the world. I also think my decision to study the law has a big thing to do with it as well. Some of the things that I’ve realized especially in this past year are illustrative to the conversations and occasional differences in philosophy I may have had with a certain student organization I was invested in college, late night debates with my fellow La Follette classmates, and more recently, employee groups at work. Even as far back as high school and grade school I think some of these beliefs were at work and I didn’t even know it.

Short disclaimer, for what its worth, I’m not endorsing a vote for any candidate for president, as far as I’m concerned you all can and should vote for however you feel is best person for the job. I do urge that you take the time to research the candidates out and make an educated choice, as hard as it is to see through the spin and sound bites and propaganda that is what we now call the main stream media, just exercise some of that free thinking ability that we all have as human beings. With the uncertainty that the country is facing in these upcoming 4-8 years, I think this last primary push and convention season leading up to November will be a very important one.

Looking back to my political compass and mindset from the last presidential election a couple things haven’t changed at all. I’m still looking for a truly anti-war candidate, pro-civil liberties, and pro-fiscal responsibility and pro-social responsibility. What has changed since 2004 is my opinion on the way to achieve populist goals, and to what extent the “noise” in the political discussion has confused us to which party or which ideology promotes the values that I believe in. Sometimes its better to keep a healthy level of skepticism whenever ideas are reduced to sound bites and one-liners. The party who speaks about limited government in actuality becomes the big government spenders, the party of civil liberties becomes the party of pro-war party, and the party of warrant-less domestic spying.

Rain, Supply Runs

Monday, March 31st, 2008

Raining all day, this morning, afternoon, and tonight in the district, it seems like this time of year we’re stuck right in the middle in between winter and spring, and its really hard to tell whether its going to snow or rain. Its really too warm for ice, but cold enough to make you shiver on your way home late at night. Either way its soggy and humid, be sure to pack an umbrella and watch your step. In the meantime the sakura are blooming all around with a reminder that spring is just around the corner, and then theres the heat of summer to look forward to.

Had a very restful and reflective weekend at home, and milling about the city. rented the zipcar and ran some errands, went grocery shopping and as noteworthy as it is, I bought up some non-perishables as I have been meaning for a while as far as my ad-hoc emergency/disaster preparedness supply project. Not like I’m really expecting a need for all of this, but maybe its the boy scout in me thinking that it wouldn’t hurt to make as much of an effort to just be prepared for the unknown. This weekend I found some stackable 3 liter bottles of water to go with my MREs and freeze dried food supply, canned corned beef, tuna, and canned veggies. Hoping that I’ll never have a need for any of this, but like I said, it doesn’t hurt to be somewhat prepared in advance.

In other news, Badgers get upset by the cinderella and crowd favorite of the tournament, Davidson behind a hot shooting Curry. I watched most of the sweet 16 game and was very impressed with the intensity that Davidson brought to the court. Pretty bummed that they weren’t able to keep it going against Kansas after beating Wisconsin pretty handily. Now we’re left with a first time ever 4 top seeded final four. Blah, boring. I guess theres always next year to look forward.

Housing madness, march madness - sweet 16!

Thursday, March 27th, 2008

Close to the end of March and things are picking up as usual, both on the school and work ends. Looking like I’ll be attending a few conferences for work in the upcoming months, should be good to get out of the office for a change. On the school front I’m coming up on my last push month before finals, looking like it’ll be pretty busy from here on out. Doing some independent research on my own, have to say that I enjoy it a lot more than classes, although it is a lot more challenging since a lot of its well, independently driven. I think maybe after so many semesters of being force fed law its a different change of pace trying to find different angles and theoretical solutions to legal problems. In doing the literature review I’ve been pretty impressed with the level of legal analysis and arguments that have already been made and been published, a lot of them show the amount of time and effort that was probably put into coming up with them.

This has been a tough reminder about the costs and benefits of working on a degree during the evening while holding a full time job. I’ve gotten the full dose of the argument that getting real-world experience simultaneously is irreplaceable, but I think its every once in a while I get more than 4 hours of sleep I wonder whether it puts you in a position of being too stretched out. The main factor that has made me convinced that this has been all worth it is the financial situation and forecast, I’ll be coming out of school well below the average debt load, both the reported average and some of the estimates I’ve heard anecdotally. I don’t envision that I’ll be bound by any golden handcuffs so to speak, no 6 figure debt estimates like I’ve heard from some old classmates that decided to go into other fields like academia or medicine.

Knowing that these plans worked out more or less is worth some peace of mind, or relatively speaking at least. I’ve been keeping a cautious eye on the state of the financial markets and housing bubble/crash ever since moving out here back in 2004 when the market was really taking off and everyone I knew was saying buy, buy, buy before you get priced out. partly out of the reality of my situation, being right out of school, with little savings to boot, other part of my sense of the situation that it isn’t smart to take on interest-only, adjustable rate loans on a $600,000 condo or $900,000 3 bedroom townhouse, no matter what the expected appreciation rate was, and no matter the assurances from an industry expert that I could qualify with current credit and modest government salary. After crunching some numbers, I decided it was better to rent, save, and wait to see what happened. My gut said that the prices would eventually have to come down, at least to a historical average, although I had no idea when it would happen. I also reasoned that the low interest rates were temporary, as with any monetary cycle, and then when they did increase, the shocks to the holder of the mortgage would be pretty steep. an increase from 2% to 4% would represent a doubling of a monthly interest only payment, and unless my income was likely to double on a monthly basis, this was a very stupid financial deal to accept. In the meantime I reasoned that if prices didn’t come down, then the new reality is that nobody can afford to own without continue to rent and save until a combination of our salary and savings would increase to a point that we could buy something outright, or with at least a hefty down payment.

Somewhere around 2006 I starting coming across various blogs and websites that are out there that were offering an alternate opinion to what I was hearing in the main stream media about all the middle class, self-made tycoons of real estate investments, more along the lines of what I was thinking, that all of the appreciation and speculation was imaginary, and doomed to fall eventually, and maybe fall hard. They were all really good about poking holes in what were mostly absolute statements, and raising good questions about the economics of these business transactions, many of which were never raised by the mainstream media.

Now the latest trend in news stories revolve the ongoing proposals to bail out people who are stuck in depreciating real estate assets and resetting mortgages despite all of the paper-success of recent memory. I often feel like I’m in Econ 101 again reading about the pitfalls of moral hazards and individuals ignorant of their own risk curves, many of the recent news reports have talked about “average” Americans who are finding themselves suddenly in hard times financially in the recent downturn. There are a few things that are similar in each of these stories, first is that the individuals are living paycheck to paycheck, even making a salary that is well above the national average when some event comes along (sickness, layoff, mortgage reset) and they are unable to cope because of their lack of any savings whatsoever. Secondly there is this inability or unwillingness to face the shitty reality of the situation and make some tough financial decisions (sell the house, get another job, go on a budget), and finally there is always this call to the government to bail them out, as if they had no control over the situation.

Unfortunately it seems like too many of us have gotten so used to the assurance that a lifetime of debt is normal and sustainable both on the personal and macro levels that when it comes around and bites us in the ass it really hurts and we are unwilling to deal with it without some reflection and self sacrifice. Don’t know for sure what is around the corner, but I’m not too optimistic overall. The volume of the message that all of this is unsustainable in the long run is getting louder with each multi-bullion dollar bailout of a bank, each FED rate cut, each report of housing prices crashing and industry layoffs.

Badgers make a sweet 16 run, and are matched up with the tourney’s cinderella 10-seeded Davidson, who knocked out area favorite 2-seeded Georgetown for a shot at the elite 8, and final 4. Seems like de ja vu from the last time Wisconsin made it this far, there was talk about them lucking out playing lower seeded teams all due to a lot of upsets in the bracket.

busy life, new work assignment, march madness

Friday, March 21st, 2008

Another busy few weeks between posts, mostly been bogged down at work wrapping up some things here and there and everywhere. I ended up trying to beat the clock showing up a few hours earlier than usual, catching the 1st or 2nd train into the city, and staying a few hours later, it became a new paradigm for me to leave and get back home in darkness. At least I’m fortunate enough to have a cubicle next to a window, otherwise I wouldn’t see the sun at all these past few weeks.

Looking like on this new assignment, there will be some travel in store, a welcome change of pace from the past year or so long job that I’ve been assigned to. I say this even though I was never much of a fan for work travel - true, its nice to be able to go to far away cities on your employer’s dime, but really, you end up working most of the time anyway, and don’t really get to see much or experience much of the new city that your visiting at all. Since I started working full time after grad school, I’ve only been on a handful of trips, and my memories of them were all very productive, but also busy, sleep deprived, and jet-lagged. Adding to it, the places I was traveling weren’t your usual destinations, kind of off the beaten path, which meant there really wasn’t much to do during the free time that I did have after work.

Plus theres this challenge of juggling night classes, the way I have them lined up this semester is all stacked on two days, so if I have to miss a day for work, it means I have to make arrangements for 3 classes all at once. Hopefully I’ll be able to keep the missed days to a minimum. I’m also finalizing my last handful of classes for the next year or so, still can’t believe that I’m almost done with this degree.

Meanwhile march madness is in full swing, Badgers are back in the big dance, after winning both the Big Ten regular season, they dominated the Big Ten tournament and got a 3 seed in the Midwest bracket of the NCAA. I have a feeling that they’ll go a lot farther this year with the big man center back in commission. Last year they were pretty tough, but had injuries down the stretch, ended up getting upset by UNLV in the second round.

Long time no see

Monday, March 3rd, 2008

Been about a month between actual entries, once again life gets busy and there hasn’t been too much time to stop and actually write something down. Had a good trip out west, will have to write about that with some pictures when I get around to it. Meanwhile life goes on I suppose, I’m getting pretty tired of the daily grind, especially when lately it seems like its much ado about nothing at all. Its an ongoing struggle seeing and learning one thing in school, and then seeing the opposite at work, sometimes vice versa, either way it can be either uplifting or discouraging. The study of law is a different animal, in some ways its hyper theoretical, studied in a vacuum, just like other ivory tower disciplines. In other ways its quite real and hard hitting, when it comes to basic procedure and due process. At the same time work has the theoretical process on how work is supposed to go, contrasted with the imperfect reality of how things play out and how people actually interact. I have to say that I’m quite proud of how I’ve been able to balance both day work and night school, so far neither has really intruded into the other one in a negative way, mostly because there has been so much overlap between the two. It is discouraging sometimes when it feels like I’m the only one that really sees it though.

In the meantime I’m cautiously keeping an eye on the world markets and talk of credit crisis in the international banks going hand in hand with the ongoing housing crash. Amazingly there are people I know that are actually jumping for an opportunity to buy, citing lower prices than a few months ago, and of course that old famous phrase, “its always a good time to buy.” For me I’d have to think long and hard before locking myself down to any large asset, especially going into a huge amount of debt as well. The more I read about the market conditions makes me think that liquidity may be the way to go for the short term at least.

This is especially in recent times where even going grocery shopping I have started to notice more and more the reality of inflation - it used to be just classroom term, or a short paper topic for economics at KCC, but now its glaring me in the eye every I go to the grocery store. You don’t have to be ultra price conscious to notice that the dollar doesn’t buy as much as it used to. Just as no market boom or investment rule of thumb lasts forever, and really no job sector is really as stable as we would hope to be. Obviously as things start slowing down more the service sector and retail sectors will start to tighten up, but eventually so will governments, local, state and even the federal levels. Is this the calm before the storm?

I’ve also been a little disturbed at how calm or nonchalant some people are about everything. I’ve heard from more than one person that they think that the powers to be will not let things get too bad, they won’t let the dollar crash too much. While I don’t deny that there must be very powerful forces out there that would be hurt from a shock to the US dollar, I’m not so optimistic that they haven’t already hedged their bets to profit from a dollar crash, and when it all hits that all of the rest of us will be left holding the bag. Thats usually how it is. I really hope I’m wrong, but my gut isn’t comforting me very much.

There is something worth mentioning that my generation has been the beneficiary of the one of the longest bull markets, by some estimates since 1982, meaning that we’ve never had a period of economic slowdown, never had a tough period for finding jobs, never had anything major barriers to access to credit. Both have contributed to a decent and increasing quality of life, either from actual income, or more perceived quality of life from cheap credit at low interest rates. As businesses start tightening their belts and laying people off, as banks stop giving out loans without ample capital or credit ratings, this will ultimately result in a shift in the American way of life as we currently know it, a shift that I wonder we are all adequately prepared for, both financially and psychologically.

Fed reserve rate, Inflation, soda machines

Tuesday, September 18th, 2007

Busy month/week/days, just a few observations and and some linkes for now:

The DOW shot up 250+ today on news of the federal reserve rate being cut from 5.25% to 4.75% - good news for stockholders and people with a lot of debt……bad news for everyone in long run in terms of inflation and the overall strength of the dollar (The Euro is already at an all time high against the dollar) There is also talk about the overall strength of the economy being in bad shape, and there is a recession looming around the corner. It might prove to be a temporary fix and ignoring a much much larger problem.

Meanwhile just today the soda machine at work just went from $1.25 to $1.35 coincidence?

Linkes for 9/18/2007:
Obama Tax plan iteresting ideas
Gold at $718/ounce and climbing
Glen Grant Threads and Obake stories starbulletin | wiki | hawaiistories

6 years later

Tuesday, September 11th, 2007

6th anniversary of the 9-11 attacks. I have to wonder how edgier do people still get on this day, for the symbolic meaning and do they change their daily schedule? or do they just go to work like any other day. I did happen to get on the train earlier than usual, not like it makes much of a difference, but one thought that has crossed my mind living out here is to be wary of big crowds of people. The metro has been getting more and more crowded lately, but it is usually during set periods around rush hour. Today it was relatively packed for being before rush hour, I wonder if the date had anything to do with getting people up earlier to work.

I got distracted for a bit from studying watching some youtube clips, one was a cnn clip the day after and you could see the tickers underneath talking about events being canceled, rolling casualty reports, and a graphic banner saying “America under attack.” It reminded of the tense few days following the attacks when most of the conversations about it was that of shock, surprise, sometimes jumping to anger and calls for retribution. I was back in Honolulu and was listening to a lot of AM radio on my way between work and the court, and it was my first real realization as to how much the right wing had taken over the radio waves who’s anger seemed to contrast with the relatively calm demeanor of the TV news casters. The radio folks said that they were angry for America, angry for justice, angry for an explanation to how and why this could have happened. The fact that their views and opinions were being broadcast over the airwaves give them a false sense of credibility, as in time I started hearing the same irrational arguments from some people I would run into in the days after the attack.

Some of the other youtube clips going around that I think capture the mindset at the time - 9-11 calls from one of the hijacked planes, and two from people trapped in the burning towers. One more memorable one was a rolling camera showing smoldering flames juxtaposed with the audio of the phone call right up until the point the towers came down. The clips display a swarm of human emotions, at one point the sheer terror comes out in the voice a caller realizes that they are probably going to die in the burning, at one another moment lashing out in anger at the operator, as if yelling at the operator is lucky to be in an air conditioned building far away is going to improve the situation, and that emergency personnel are supposed to climb 100+ flights of stairs in a burning building in a cinch. Then there is the operator who is trying to keep the callers calm, while both probably know the desperate circumstances that are unfolding.

What the clips also show is in part the mindset of Americans, pursuing their careers and dreams, in a sense living oblivious to the fact that the very tower they go to work everyday has been a repeated target for terrorist attacks, represents a symbol of American capitalism and economic dominance, fueling the foreign policy that impacts that it has on people in far corners of the world, all out of sight, out of mind. They also are oblivious to the vulnerability that the “soft” target and the potential chaos that a direct attack would have on the structure, and more importantly, any escape routes for an evacuation.  On any given day the trains, elevators, phone lines are supposed to work. When an emergency happens, the fire and police are supposed to get there and do their job. But when the unthinkable happens, things are quickly brought back down to the basic chaos and nothing is for certain anymore.

Watching one of these clips in particular I feel very torn, on the one hand I feel horrible for the people on the other line and can’t imagine what it would be like to see the world around you literally burning and crashing down.  On the other hand I am irritated again at more moments of anger directed at the emergency operator, accusingly as if he or she is doing anything but trying to sort out what has just happened and try to get first responders to the callers locations.  In the face of certain death blaming a complete stranger over the phone is an understandably human reaction, but it reeks of “how dare you” or “why did this happen to me?”  Then there is the image of the towers crashing down and you hear a gut-wrenching crack over the phone, with the voice screaming out to god in a reminder that all the people stuck in the tower were in fact doomed the entire time.

I’m also reminded that the tragedies were documented through American newsmedia and audio don’t t make it any less horrific to the loss of life and human suffering that followed in retaliation for 9-11.  No clips exist to show us about the people trapped in the burning buildings in the first weeks of the war, or the bombing victims in the years of occupation that followed.  6 years after the attacks of 9-11, and now after 5 years of war waged in its name I am still struggling with what the lessons learned are for Americans as a whole. If talk of an upcoming 3rd war in the middle east is credible and plans are being made, then it is only a matter of time before there might be another set of frantic final 9-11 calls made to an operator in an American city. While this time the lesson of 9-11 would give them a sense of who might’ve committed these attacks, they still would probably not understand why.

Linkes 9/11/2007
NORFED private currency
Austin Gold Company
Brazen home invasion attempted SA scary.
Diego Garcia South Indian base
DOD and Co. bling bling
Ron Paul Video on youtube

Earth Box Project

Tuesday, June 19th, 2007

Mid June in the district and the heat is on, literally. One thing I haven’t quite gotten used to is the extreme heat that comes around this time of year. Today coming back from class was brutal since for some reason some genius decided to turn off the air conditioning in the building with heat indexes of 100. At 9pm it was still about 90, or 96 or so with the heat index. Another part of summer in DC is the torrential rainshowers that come hand and hand with all that humidity in the air. Last Thursday it was pouring so bad there were rivers in the streets. Fortunately the drain outside my door is working well, no flooded basement apartment yet, knock on wood.

For a side project this summer I drove up to MD this past weekend to get an Earth Box, supposedly an idiot-proof planter system that has high yields for growing small scale fruits and vegetables. It came with some fertilizer, CaCO3 mix for growing tomatoes and supposedly set up with a reservoir system that makes it impossible for you to over or under water the plants. I started off with a celebrity tomato plant, some Thai basil for pho, Chinese parsley and Italian basil for pasta. I’m in the process of germinating some seeds to see if I grow some Okinawan goya as well although I don’t know if it’ll work.

I think it might be my mom’s influence as well who grows just about everything in her yard back home. Or part of it is from reading articles about citizens living on an isolated island giving up their domestic agricultural industries (AKA food?) based on the faith that the regular shipments of cargo won’t be affected by a spike in oil prices or geopolitical crisis. Maybe its this lingering concern that maybe one day the consumption bubble will burst and those who have skills in producing goods will be in a better position than those who just produce services.

Who knows, maybe trying to grow stuff, even on a micro-scale and mostly symbolic way may be the start of a personal struggle with this consumer identity that pretty much become a way of life. I recall reading lots of articles in grad school and around the web talking about the shift from manufacturing and agriculture to strictly service industry, and what are the potential implications of this in the long term economies of the world. While all economies require producers of goods and consumers of those goods, and that as economies become more service-based, they are more driven by consumption of goods produced in other countries. As things stand now the service-industry countries are the richer ones, more or less dictating the market prices while importing the hard goods that their respective companies no longer produce because it costs cheaper to buy it overseas.

Eventually we become a nation of service providers who produce nothing really other than our “expertise” which unfortunately can sometimes materialize in bureaucracy, pushing paper skills and a lot of bullshit. Irony, I think this service skill set describes me and pretty much everyone I know in terms of our formal education - although its true my day job is in the production of policy analysis, research, and reports, and eventually I’ll be providing legal services or producing legal work products, it would be nice to actually produce or create something down to earth once in a while. Also with this outsourcing there are very serious vulnerabilities to service industry-based economies as a result of this shift, we become more dependent on international political stability, free trade trade agreements, and of course cheap oil to transport the goods that we consume but do not produce. Everything is dependent on cheap energy for communications and transportation, otherwise the service-based industries would eventually starve.

One sign of becoming a yuppie is to do more grocery shopping at Whole Foods and be tempted by all of their latest promotions and organic goodies, and actually not be totally fazed out by the higher prices. I think for some produce and meats I definitely do taste a difference. I have begun to appreciate quality over quantity, with some exception of course. I remember talking to a friend about his refusal to buy anything organic on the basis that it is overpriced for the amount of food you actually get. This is someone who loves to shop at Walmart, and refuses to even consider the arguments presented in Fast Food Nation, or Super-Size me as having any merit at all.

I do agree that part of being an informed consumer, you have to remind yourself the misconceptions of organic food in general, especially lately how it has become more a marketing tactic. Maybe it always was, maybe not, who knows. In part I suppose we have to trust our own judgment and make our own decisions for what a particular good or service is worth. Again, everything is relative, overhearing a conversation at the the local farmer’s market gave another perspective as the person was bashing whole foods as an evil corporation.

Linkes for June 11-19
Love Thy Neighbor bombs, with apologies to Stanislaw Lem
Colleges revolt against U.S. News Rankings - Law schools to follow?
Secrecy in today’s world
National Bitter Melon Council AKA Goya
Cosumerist blog updated frequently
Top ten Copyright myths

2007_0617WashDC05521.JPG2007_0617WashDC05531.JPG

Semester #4 - One Month Mark

Wednesday, April 11th, 2007

About a month away from completing my 4th semester, and 2nd year as an evening student. While saving any overly reflective comments until I’m actually through the gate and survived the seasonal trials and stress that comes with studying the law part time while juggling a full time day job, I’ll say that things have been progressing along, slowly but surely. My cases are becoming easier to read, and the legal reasoning has become clearer and easier to spot quickly. This is not to say that any of the material has gotten any easier, but I as usual, I’m finding ways to adapt and push forward when faced with a challenge. I think a lot of this has to do with my choice of classes this past summer and fall semester, I kind of went off the beaten path by enrolling in a clinical program which in retrospect helped put all of this training into context. In many ways it was the human element that I found missing from my first year - brought back some memories of taking pre-med science courses and craving for something more fundamental to a professional field of study.

I’m looking into my classes for the next couple of years, weighing options with the required staple and bar-related courses. There are some that I’m having a hard time conceptualizing why I would need to take, and then there are others that I would like to take, but am limited based on my evening hours schedule. I’m finding myself drawn to similar topics as I did back at La Follette, more along the public policy route, with some twists and turns.

Recent discussion in class dealt with the Grutter v. Bollinger case involving affirmative action policies at the University of Michigan. Reading the case I’m sure struck a nerve among many of my classmates in the sense that the case involved a haole student who was denied admission to an “elite law school” but who probably had a similar LSAT/GPA profile as many of us sitting in the classroom. Instead of “settling” for a lower ranked law school, the student decided to sue the university claiming racial discrimination. There has been some talk recently about law school rankings which inevitably enters the law student’s mind because they seem to matter so much for employment, and overall assurances that you’re not wasting 3-4 years of your live on a degree that will be perceived marginally good enough, depending on the circle you associate with, of course.

My take on affirmative action to me has always been mixed. On one hand I think that we cannot deny the history (and disturbingly recent history) of racial discrimination and we as a society should be actively engaging it. On the other hand I do not think that it is a fair system, and that it can also breed some of the same discrimination and racial tensions if it is not applied equitably. It definitely has its limits as with any other law or policy, the ultimate goal is to discriminate one class against another. in free market terms, there are always winners and losers, we as society have to decide who wins, who loses, by how much, and for how long.  I think I agree most with O’Connor’s comment in the case that she could envision that 25 years from now there might not be a need for affirmative action.  I don’t know about the prediction of 25 years by itself, but I do agree with the broad concept of using racial preferences to address a historical wrong if it meets a certain standard of scrutiny - however they can’t be sustained indefinitely forever.  Of course saying when the playing field is truly “level” is the hard part.

More housing madness

Wednesday, March 21st, 2007

For the several months now I’ve been following the coverage of several housing related blogs and informational websites that present a very compelling list of arguments why it might be a very bad idea to buy real estate in the current market conditions. Although many of them are focusing on the San Francisco bay area, I think the rationale can be applied to other metro areas that have seen exponential rises in housing prices since 2000. I think the authors have to have laid out very well reasoned yet painfully simple economic analysis which I have yet to see sufficient evidence on the other side to present a compelling case. One author addresses just about every sales pitch that has been thrown around by real estate agents and mortgage brokers about why everyone should be buying a house, and its always a good time to buy.

Anyone who has taken a high school class in economics, or even glanced at an Econ 101 book should be able to understand why many of the pro-housing advocates in this current market make no sense at all in their sales pitches. Unfortunately emotion and fear of market exclusion is a very effective tool at getting people to stop using their heads and make very poor financial decisions that could haunt them for the rest of their lives. In many ways I liken the current state of the real estate industry a lot like the diamond industry, the luxury sports car industry, selling overpriced, over-marketed consumer goods that are suck up a substantial amount of the average person’s disposable income, guaranteed to depreciate in value, and ultimately amount to nothing more than another meaningless status symbol when it really should be something more practical: a roof over your head and land to maintain and maybe pass on to your heirs one day.

The subprime stock implosion and mainstream media coverage of toxic/exotic loans that sound a lot like credit cards with their low introductory rates that double or quadruple after a couple of years is all troubling. Especially since a lot of these loans were apparently given to all being given to people who normally could not qualify for a standard, fixed rate loan. They were banking on the fact that their houses would appreciate at 25%, 50% a year or something, and they would eventually sell it for a profit, or refinance the mortgage and take more cash out on the equity. Unfortunately now that the real estate market is tanking, it looks like it’ll just get worse as more and more mortgages reset to the higher rates, and more foreclosures go through. In the next couple of years there might be a lot of broke homeless people with bad credit finding it hard to find someplace to even rent.

I think that everyone who is thinking about buying a house or condo should at least read and digest the wealth of information available online before taking the debt plunge. The housing market is so out of whack right now that it could be financially fatal to buy in the current inflated market conditions.

Housing Blog Linkes:
The Bubble Meter
Housing Panic
Marin Bubble
Hawaii Real Estate bubble
DC housing blues