With a hard fought victory in the meadowlands, the Patriots go 16-0 in an amazing season with a number of dominating victories along with a few close come from behind games. I had a feeling that they would be in good shape to make a playoff run, but to get the top seed and home field advantage through the playoffs and to cap off an undefeated season was pretty unexpected, at least to me. New England players now hold a bunch of league records, in addition to the first undefeated regular season since 1972, records for total points scored, passing and receiving touchdowns in a regular season. The downside is that after watching such a dominating regular season anything short of a trip to Glendale would be a letdown. I’m hoping that there are at least 2-3 more wins for the Pats this year. We’ll see if they can keep it up in a couple weeks.
With all this success comes the animosity from fans from the other 31 pro teams. It’s been interesting to listen and read all of the trash talking and hate going around about officiating, coaching personalities, and even how the entire season is a joke because of videotaping of an opposing signals at the beginning of the season. Thinking about all of the animosity building towards one football team or another brings to mind cult sociology, as Durkheim described them. People in society have a tendency to rally around a symbol of unity, social identity. In ancient societies it was a totem that the village warriors rallied around in a bubbling effervescence of village pride and celebration of identity. Sports matches between rival villages were often used as a violent, but non-lethal alternative to war. The identifying power that the totem has in society creates a whole sub-culture of village warriors, the fan base which in the frenzy of effervescence, sometimes get caught up in the fray.
Go to a single Big Ten school football game with 80,000+ people in the stands, and just experience the sheer energy of the crowd through the highs and lows of the game. The traditional cheers, and chants serve as celebration of collective identity, a sea of school colors all give a sense of unity. Likewise when the brave (or foolish) fan from the visiting team invades the student section of the home team, he is literally attacked, for the most part with verbal taunts and gestures, usually it’s in all good fun. However I have heard of games where paper cups full of piss are flung around at a particular school, in retribution for the visiting team allegedly running up the score. For many fans, its not just a game, but a matter of personal pride and identity. There is also a clip going around the internet of a mob of the losing schools’ fans bombarding a smaller group of visiting fans with beer bottles.
In the world of college football, fierce debate has gone on about how to crown a national champion, which is currently done by a weekly ranking poll of various teams. In order to break into the upper echelon of post season bowls, a team has to impress the poll voters in that they are worthy enough of a shot at the title, or at the least to compete with the traditionally elite. Some of this all takes an interesting but ridiculous tone as to the symbolism of what a big name, prime time, nationally televised game really means. UH-UGA quickly becomes WAC vs. SEC, non-BCS vs. BCS, Hawaii (the state) vs. Georgia (the state). Even the local news coverage takes on an interesting tone of referring fans as now cultural representatives to the host city. Every day for the past few weeks the Honolulu advertiser does a story about the cross cultural ties between Hawaii and New Orleans, or how UH fans are partying it up in the French Quarter, buying stuff and helping to contribute to the local community still recovering from hurricane Katrina. The dedicated Warrior football fans become ambassadors of Hawaii to the mainland.
The other aspect of modern day totemism that I would be interested in how Durkheim would’ve analyzed in is how sports fans have put up fan blogs and discussion forums on the various articles floating around on the internet. For every celebrated match up, both team’s fans are quick to boast about their respective team’s strengths, the abilities of its star players, coaching staff, and go on to predict the outcome of the football game. There is usually a bit of comment about each team’s past laurels, from the current season as well as past seasons, all evidence on the superiority of one’s team. One of the forums I browsed through recently had some interesting turns, as the debate on the final football score in the sugar bowl went from discussing football to discussing the quality of public education at the UH-Manoa vs. the UGA. Another one went into the greater debate on what it means to be a local (Hawaiian) vs. a mainland Wannabee local. This is an ongoing debate that revolves around Hawaii’s star quarterback and his troubled past before he came to Hawaii.